|
|
| Name (country of origin) |
Encourage |
Discourage |
No opinion |
| Ban Ki-Moon (South Korea) |
14 |
0 |
1 |
| Sashi Tharoor (India) |
10 |
3 (1 pm) |
2 |
| Vaira Vike-Freiberga (Latvia) |
5 |
6 (2 pm) |
4 |
| Surakiart Sathirathai (Thailand) | 4 |
7 (2 pm) |
4 |
| Ashraf Ghani (Afghanistan) | 4 |
11 (3 pm) |
0 |
| Zeid al-Hussein (Jordan) | 2 |
8 (1 pm) |
5 |
Despite his second place finish, Sashi Tharoor of India conceded the race to Mr. Ki-Moon and ended his quest for the post. US Ambassador John Bolton was reported to say that the Security Council will move to hold a formal vote on Monday morning October 9. It is possible, but unlikely, that other candidates may still be nominated before then. If as expected Mr. Ki-Moon wins this formal vote his name will be submitted to the 192 member General Assembly for approval.
Latvia's president, Dr. Vaira Vike-Freiberga came in third, as she had in Friday's vote, but with the number of positive votes in her favor dropping from 7 to 5. Though the balloting is secret in the sense that it is not known how each country voted it is widely assumed that the two negative votes cast against Mrs. Vike-Freiberga by permanent members of the Council came from Russia and China. A statement posted Tuesday, Oct. 3 on her web site www.president.lv said she took a "realistic view" of the results of the fourth straw-poll. The President also stated she felt satisfied by the support her candidacy had received and that it had shown that the Secretary-General should be chosen in a more open, transparent and democratic process based on the candidates' qualifications and with less attention to regional rotation. She went on to say she felt her candidacy had been successful in promoting wider discussion about how the UN Secretary-General is selected and about the need to continue UN reforms.
The web sites of a number of NGO's have closely followed the selection process, among them www.unsg.org , www.centerforunreform.org and www.unwatch.org . Some commentators on these NGO sites and the international media have noted an striking correlation in the amount of foreign aid South Korea has been sending to current members of the Security Council since Mr. Ki-Moon announced his candidacy for the UN post in February. Among them the The Times of London http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,25689-2380336_1,00.html .
On Thursday evening, September 28, Dr. Vaira Vike-Freiberga, the president of Latvia, took third place in the latest of a series of informal votes among Security Council members that is part of the process in choosing the next UN Secretary-General. An article on UN related web log , www.unsg.org noted that "it was Latvia's President Vaira Vike-Freiberga that achieved a surprise victory, pushing past the other challengers to secure an impressive if not strong third place standing. On top of being the only non-Asian in the race, this was an outstanding showing for a candidate that entered the race less than two weeks ago."
As in the previous two "straw polls" the fifteen members of the Security Council each submitted its opinion of each candidate without distinguishing between the five permanent or the ten rotating members of the council. Thus it is not yet known if any of the negative or "discourage" votes received by each candidate came from the Council members with veto power to block any nominee.
The results of the poll, ordered by each candidate's level of support, are as follows:
| Name (country of origin) | Encourage | Discourage | No opinion |
| Ban Ki-Moon (South Korea) | 13 | 1 | 1 |
| Sashi Tharoor (India) | 8 | 3 | 4 |
| Vaira Vike-Freiberga (Latvia) | 7 | 6 | 2 |
| Surakiart Sathirathai (Thailand) | 5 | 7 | 3 |
| Zeid al-Hussein (Jordan) | 3 | 6 | 6 |
| Ashraf Ghani (Afghanistan) | 3 | 6 | 6 |
| Jayanatha Dhanapala (Sri Lanka) | 3 | 7 | 5 |
Though only Mr. Ban Ki-Moon received more than the required nine votes needed to win, he does not have the election wrapped up. It is possible that his one "discourage" came from a permanent member, which would block any chance of his election.
There is no way to tell how individual countries voted, but one can speculate that six of the seven positive votes for Mrs. Vike-Freiberga may have come from the European nations: France, United Kingdom, Denmark, Greece, Slovakia, plus the United States. Four of the six negative votes may have come from countries in the "Asian" group: China, Japan, and Qatar, plus the Russian Federation. Again, it must be emphasized that this is pure conjecture. In any case the level of support for any candidate can vary widely from poll to poll as shown in an article on www.unwatch.org where the results of all the Security Council straw-polls are compiled.
President Vike-Freiberga expressed her gratitude "for the received support and thanks all supporters of her candidacy both from the Eastern European region and beyond" in a statement posted on her web site www.president.lv .
The next informal vote is scheduled for Monday, October 2. In this poll the permanent Security-Council members will be given ballots of a different color than non-permanent members so each candidate will know if his or her path to the Secretary-General's post may be blocked by a veto.
Also on Thursday, September 28, The New York Times published on its Op-Ed page the replies to certain questions asking each of the seven candidates why they were seeking the job of UN Secretary-General. Five of the candidates, including Dr. Vaira Vike-Freiberga, responded. This Op-Ed piece may be found at www.nytimes.com .
Other Baltic organization web sites with news and information about the process of choosing the next UN Secretary-General are: www.jbanc.org , www.alausa.org , and www.latviansonline.com
On Wednesday, September 20, the nomination of Ashraf Ghani for
UN Secretary-General was announced. There are now a total of seven candidates
viewing for the title of the world's top diplomat.
These are:
Mrs.Vaira Vike-Freiberga, president of Latvia;
Mr. Ahraf Ghani, former finance minister of Afghanistan;
Mr. Ban Ki-moon, foreign minister of South Korea;
Mr. Shashi Tharoor of India, the UN under secretary-general for communications and information;
Mr. Surakiart Sathirathai, deputy prime minister of Thailand;
Prince Zeid Ra'ad al-Hussein, ambassador of Jordan to the UN;
and Mr. Jayanatha Dhanapala of Sri Lanka, former UN under secretary-general for disarmament.
The 15 member UN Security Council has the task of choosing one candidate who is then must be approved by a majority of the 192 UN member countries. In order to gauge how much support each candidate has within the Council, informal votes or "straw polls" are conducted. Prior to the nominations of Mrs. Vike-Freiberga and Mr. Ghani, two such polls had taken place, the first on July 24 and another on September 14. Prince al-Hussein entered the race after the first poll. In these polls Council members checked one of three boxes next to each declared candidate's name to indicate an opinion of "encourage", "discourage" or "no opinion". In the last two polls Mr. Ki-moon came in first followed closely by Mr. Tharoor. They were followed by Mr. Sathirathai, Prince al-Hussein and lastly by Mr. Dhanapala. The recent military coup in Thailand has complicated Mr. Sathirathai's candidacy.
The first two votes by secret ballot did not make any distinction between the votes of five permanent veto-wielding Security-Council members and those of the ten non-permanent members who serve two-year terms. It is expected that in the next vote scheduled for September 28 the permanent members: China; France; the Russian Federation; the United Kingdom; and the United States, will cast their votes with ballots of a different color than the rotating members, so as to be able to tell if a permanent member intends to veto the candidacy of any nominee. The non-permanent members now serving in the Security Council are: Argentina, Republic of the Congo, Denmark, Ghana, Greece, Japan, Peru, Qatar, Slovakia, and the United Republic of Tanzania.
On Tuesday, September 19, President Vike-Freiberga gave an address before the 61st session of the United Nations General Assembly. The full text of her address is also available on www.president.lv .
On Friday, September 15, 2006 the UN delegations of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania in New York submitted the nomination of Dr. Vaira Vike-Freiberga, currently the president of Latvia, to be the next Secretary-General of the United Nations. The nomination was submitted to Ambassador Adamantios Vassilakis of Greece who is currently serving as president of the UN Security Council. Thus President Vike-Freiberga becomes the sixth person but the first woman formally nominated for the post.
In a statement issued the same day, Dr. Vike-Freiberga noted that "The time has come for a woman to be taken seriously as a candidate for this prestigious position." She went on to say that no Secretary-General has come from the Eastern European group. regarding her qualifications Dr. Vike-Freiberga cited her active participation in various UN initiatives since her election as President of Latvia in 1999. The current Secretary-General, Kofi Annan appointed her Special Envoy on UN Reform in 2005. Dr. Vike-Freiberga emphasized to need to restore trust in the UN and make it capable of resolving the challenges of poverty, inequality, insecurity and violence. She also stressed the importance of dialogue between civilizations. The full text of the President's statement is available at the web site of the Chancery of the President of Latvia www.president.lv .
The next hurdle to be overcome by the candidates to succeed Kofi Annan as the next Secretary-General is an informal and secret "straw poll" among the 15 members of the Security Council to be held September 28. In the most recent straw poll, Ban Ki-Moon, Foreign Minister of South Korea, had a significant but not overwhelming lead. The Security Council has 5 permanent members: China; France; the Russian Federation; the United Kingdom; and the United States, and 10 non-permanent members elected for overlapping 2-year terms. Currently the ten rotating members are: Argentina, Republic of the Congo, Denmark, Ghana, Greece, Japan, Peru, Qatar, Slovakia, and the United Republic of Tanzania. The veto power held by the permanent members of the Security Council has not been applied to the earlier straw polls but can ultimately be used to block eventual Security Council approval of any nominee. After the Security Council gives its approval, the candidate must gain a majority of votes in the General Assembly, where all 192 UN members have one vote.
Supporters of the idea that a woman should lead the United Nations have established a web site based in France where individuals can sign a petition: www.chooseawomanforun.eu .
The Baltic Association to the United
Nations (BATUN) is a department of United Baltic Appeal, Inc.
(UBA), an independent, not-for-profit, non-governmental organization.
UBA-BATUN is funded solely by membership dues and donations. UBA-BATUN receives no government support of any kind, directly or indirectly.
UBA-BATUN's mission is to:
Maintain an independent, non-governmental, and non-partisan Baltic presence at the United Nations and other relevant international forums. Monitor the activities of the United Nations and other international forums and inform all interested persons about developments at these forums which impact the Baltic nations of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania.
Promote civic interest and participation in the formulation of foreign policy within Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, as well as in the host countries of Baltic communities worldwide. Promote public awareness and informed discussion on issues of international concern affecting Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania. Provide assistance to the United Nations Associations of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania. Encourage the people of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania, as well as Estonians, Latvians and Lithuanians worldwide, to cooperate on issues of common concern for the mutual benefit of all.
Educate the world public and governments about the history, culture, and current affairs of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania. Expose and counter the campaign of disinformation, waged mainly by the government of the Russian Federation, against Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania. Promote respect for the Baltic nations and their history by exposing and countering false, misleading or denigrating statements, made either out of ignorance or malice, against Estonians, Latvians and Lithuanians.
Pressure the government of the Russian Federation and Russia’s society as a whole to acknowledge and atone for the crimes committed by the Soviet Union against the people of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania.
Support international efforts to condemn the crimes of communism.
Work to make the United Nations and other international forums more effective and dedicated to their stated principles. Convince UN member states and non-governmental organizations to speak out and take appropriate action at international forums in response to human rights violations by the Russian Federation, Belarus and any other government that demonstrates consistent disregard of internationally recognized human rights standards. Urge the United Nations and other international forums to counter the military intimidation by the Russian Federation of neighboring countries and support efforts seeking the removal of Russian troops from Georgia and Moldova.
Draw the attention of the international community to the status of and situation in Kaliningrad, the Russian enclave bordering Lithuania and Poland, where the combination of a needlessly heavy military presence, lawlessness, and deteriorating environmental and public health situation threatens the surrounding region.
Promote as a positive example the democratic and economic emergence and transformation of the Baltic nations from Soviet totalitarianism and Russian imperialism, for other countries where progress has been slow or has even reversed. Support the democratic and human rights movements in Belarus, the Russian Federation, Ukraine, Moldova, Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan.
To read how UBA-BATUN is fulfilling its mission, please click on "Current Projects", at the top of this page.
A report is available of
events and Baltic Activities at the 60th session of the
UN Commission on Human Rights which met in Geneva in February-March of 2004. To
view the report please CLICK HERE.
© United Baltic Appeal, Inc., 2004-2006. The information on this site may be freely printed out, as well as quoted and distributed, on condition that the UBA-BATUN www.batun.org web pages are cited as the source.